The idea that the American government can snatch anyone up, with a green card/legal documentation in the name of disliking what they publicly advocate for sets a perilous precedent.
Mahmoud Khalil was followed by government agents wearing plain clothes, abducted in front of his eight-month pregnant wife because of his pro-Palestine advocacy at Columbia. He has legal documentation, and he was practicing his free speech. The Trump administration made the deliberate move of shipping him to Louisiana after the abduction because they know that the judges there are more likely to deport them than the judges in a liberal state.
If Mahmoud Khalil is deported, they cannot send him back to Palestine because of the non-existent government relationship, so they'll send him to Panama, where he will be fighting a political limbo of residency across multiple countries. At the same time, his pregnant wife gives birth without her husband’s physical support.
The Republican party prides itself on caring about the Constitution, yet the acting director of ICE, Tom Homan, says “free speech has limitations":
To make matters worse, the US government seems to rely on Marco Rubio's decision that Khalil’s “presence or activities in the United States would have serious adverse foreign policy consequences for the United States."
And listen, I don’t care where you land on the political spectrum. Regardless of if you agree with Khalil’s political activism or not, this deportation mission against him is the beginning of a path that questions what freedom of speech in America means. People like you and I, who have publicly shown our political beliefs online, are at risk of deportation if the Trump administration doesn’t like what we have to say at this rate.
Khalil will be the blueprint to investigate, harass, abduct and illegally deport Americans:
Members of the Progressive Democratic Caucus have come together to write a letter to Secretary Kristi Noam, and notable politicians like Jasmine Crockett and Ilhan Omar have signed the letter. However, I’m afraid this doesn’t hold much weight against an administration that does whatever it wants to do based on the vibes of that day.
We need more democrats to protest against this gross violation of the 1st amendment right we should all be afforded (as well as Republicans, but you know). NYC assembly member and now mayoral candidate for New York City uploaded this video of himself confronting the Border czar Tom Holman:
The case of Mahmoud Khalil highlights a disturbing trend where the U.S. government seeks to punish individuals for exercising their fundamental right to free speech. The potential deportation of Khalil—based on his pro-Palestine advocacy—sets a dangerous precedent that undermines the core principles of the First Amendment.
This chilling reality doesn't just affect those with green cards or legal documentation; it creates a broader threat to anyone who publicly expresses political beliefs deemed undesirable by those in power. Whether one agrees or disagrees with Khalil's views, the attack on his right to speak freely without fear of persecution should alarm all Americans, regardless of political affiliation.
The potential for such actions to be used as a blueprint for future government overreach is real and calls for a united, bipartisan effort to defend the freedom of speech central to our democracy. The time to act is before this precedent becomes a norm that puts every American at risk of losing their voice.
This is VERY disturbing!! I participate in demonstrations at least twice a week and I will be making a sign for Mahmoud! I was furious with Homan comparing Mahmoud’s exercise of free speech as synonymous with yelling FIRE in a crowded movie theater! They are NOT equivalent. He also said slander was not acceptable as free speech! And yet Homan has no problem with Musk publicly calling Mark Kelly (astronaut, Navy pilot, U. S. Senator a TRAITOR!
Fascism 101. And today—“don’t criticize ANY policy”. Next is insurrection act, emergency declarations, crackdowns etc. We should cut to the chase NOW and see to it while we have impassioned pluralistic strength. Arundhati Roy, Ruth Ben-Ghiat, Rothkopf et al told us, a host of other countries this century and last showed us what we should have humbled ourselves to hear and see.